Ron Bonjean, President of The Bonjean Company, said:
“Most Americans don’t understand the arcane rules of the United States Senate. What they do understand are bipartisan accomplishments reached by Congress on issues like the economy, health care and climate change. Therefore, the 60 seat threshold might only serve the Democrats well on procedural votes.”
Lanny J. Davis, Pundits Blog contributor, said:
“Al Franken’s biggest impact in joining the Senate is Al Franken himself - he’s smart, progressive, and a lot more pragmatic than his talk show persona might suggest. If he follows Hillary Clinton’s method - be a workhorse, not a shorthouse - he will have an immense impact.”
John Samples, Director of the Center for Representative Government at the Cato Institute, said:
“Al Franken’s court-awarded victory in Minnesota will not completely end filibusters and gridlock in the Senate. His victory is much less significant than what many congressional observers are saying.
It has, however, affected how the Democratic leadership will need to distribute pork to bring controversial legislation to a vote.
If Franken had lost, Democratic leaders would have needed to attract at least one Republican vote to end a filibuster. Norm Coleman, Franken’s opponent, was not likely to be that vote. Coleman’s voting record in 2008 was much less liberal than the two Republicans from Maine. One of those two could have extracted benefits for Maine voters in exchange for agreeing to override a filibuster. Now their votes may matter less, and voters in Maine should expect less from Washington for the time being. READ THE FULL RESPONSE HERE.
Larry J. Sabato, Director of the UVA Center for Politics and professor of politics, said:
“Obviously, it’s both, depending on the day and circumstance. The Senate has many razor-thin votes, and this one additional Democrat will make the difference on some nominations and controversial policy issues. At the same time, the 60-mark is overemphasized. Senators aren’t automatons, or as Trent Lott put it in his book title, rounding up senators for anything is like ‘herding cats.’”
Grover Norquist, President of Americans for Tax Reform, said:
“One more vote always matters.”
Dean Baker, Co-Director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research, said:
The point is not that reaching 60 seals everything for the Dems either in reality or symbolically. The point is that it is a big step towards changing the dynamics on important votes.
By making it substantially easier to get to sixty on key votes, the additional seat changes the logic for the marginal senator from being a determined holdout to being a dealmaker. There is a lot to be gained from being the 60th vote, there is little value in being 61.
There is likely to be a greater willingness by the few remaining Republican moderates to cut deals in the cases where the Dems can’t sustain a unified bloc.
Tom McClusky, Senior Vice President for FRC Action, said:
“Will this be the year of Al Franken? Or the decade? Doubtful. While Senator Franken (excuse me, a little bit of my breakfast just reappeared in my mouth as I said that) supports the out there agenda that Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) wants to push, he still does not give the Majority Leader the blessed sixty votes needed to pass some of the radical things he is proposing. Card check, Obama’s version of immigration reform, forcing taxpayers to pay for abortions, or the Democratic leaders vision of government takeover of health care - these are all to out of the mainstream for many voters, including those in conservative states with Democratic Senators. And while now it appears that Al Franken is good enough, and smart enough for the U.S. Senate - that says more about how far the Senate has fallen then how high the former comedian has risen. Only in this topsy-turvy world could the Senator from Minnesota end up making Senators like Chris Dodd with his questionable sweetheart financial deals and John Ensign with his questionable sweethearts look good by comparison. I think after a while Senator Reid might start missing Norm Coleman.”
Herbert London, President of the Hudson Institute, said:
“Franklin’s victory in Minnesota not only gives the Democrats a 60-40 edge in the United States Senate, it also offers a filibuster proof majority. There is virtually nothing the Republicans can do to offset Democratic legislative initiatives other than convincing Senator Lieberman that he should caucus with Republicans.
In my judgment, this is not merely a sad day for the Republican party; it is a sad day for the Republic when one party so dominates the legislative agenda.”
Bertha Lewis, CEO of ACORN, said
“Yes.”
READ THE LAST BIG QUESTION HERE.