Reinstatement of the Military Draft Not Necessary
Tuesday, November 21st, 2006Congressman Charlie Rangel’s renewed calls for the reinstatement of the military draft, while they might be well intentioned, seem to be nothing more than misguided attempts at criticizing this Administration and its management of the current conflict in Iraq. Congressman Rangel has stated that his legislation is intended to serve as a deterrent to keep Congress and the Administration from entering into wars, and that he believes President Bush would not have invaded Iraq if we had a draft and “members of Congress and the administration thought that their kids from their communities would be placed in harm’s way.� The fact of the matter is that each and every sailor, soldier, airman and marine is deeply cherished and no one - not the President, Congress, or Charles Rangel himself - wants them to be put in harm’s way regardless of whether they volunteered or were drafted. These men and women ARE from our communities and I think it is fair to say that the lives of every American, to include Members of Congress, have been touched by someone that is serving or has served in the armed forces. All of our brave patriots that are fighting in Iraq are important and we want them all to come home as safely and quickly as possible. The premise that we would somehow feel differently about these troops simply because they were drafted rather than having volunteered is simply not true.
There is concern among some that our military needs more troops, and I believe it would serve us well to have an open and honest debate about the size of our nation’s armed forces. However, there are no indications that a draft is necessary or that winning the war on terror and ending the conflict in Iraq cannot be accomplished with an all-volunteer force. Pentagon officials, including outgoing Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld have repeatedly stated that the all-volunteer force is working well and that the reinstatement of the draft is not necessary. Recruitment and retention numbers are high and the United States all volunteer force is as strong and determined as it has ever been. Public polls show that about seven of ten Americans oppose the reinstatement of the draft, and in 2004 the House of Representatives overwhelmingly defeated Congressman Rangel’s draft legislation by a vote of 402-2.

